|
HOSES
(article from © JM Publishing,
http://www.diy-boat.com/)
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT HOSE
Hoses are essential to keeping your boat afloat and
operative but many boats are equipped with inferior, non-marine-rated
hoses. Here’s how to survey and upgrade your boat to comply with today’s
performance and safety standards.
Story and photos by Jan Mundy
|
Non-approved
automotive hoses installed in early ‘80s on author’s 7.5hp diesel
engine: (top) cheap, highly-abrasive corrugated fuel fill shown on
right side; very thin-walled, non-Coast Guard-approved fuel
distribution line; common heater hose for raw-water exhaust shown on
left side. Note split hose |
|
wrapped over
soft heater hose (left side) to protect from abrading on bulkhead.
(bottom) Automotive heater hose connects to exhaust manifold. All
hoses have since been upgraded to marine spec after researching for
this article. |
Many boats built
before 1990 and some after, were assembled from readily available
materials, such as highly corrosive automotive wiring, inexpensive heater
and fuel line hoses and household plumbing fittings, with little concern
for boatbuilding standards, either mandatory or voluntary.
Nowadays, the
installation of most boat systems are regulated by the Coast Guard,
American Boat and Yacht Council (ABYC), National Marine Manufacturer’s
Association (NMMA), Lloyd’s and others. Though some standards are
voluntary and not always adopted by boatbuilders, you should adapt these
when replacing or upgrading components. This ensures your boat will, at
the very least, pass a survey or insurance claim if the surveyor or
adjuster is standards-literate, and you can avoid failures by inferior
products.
|
Certified
hoses for use on boats: (top) Hard-wall (“R2” designated), wet exhaust
and water intake hose, SAE J2006 rated; (middle) Coast Guard-certified
fuel fill hose that meets fire resistance (“A”) and lowest fuel
permeation (“2”) standards; (bottom) Certified fuel distribution and
return hose meets fire resistance (“A”) and highest fuel permeation
(“B”) standards. Gasoline-powered boats must have certified fuel hoses
to pass a survey or insurance claim when done by a competent surveyor
or adjuster. |
Attending a
seminar presented by Bill Shields of Trident Marine at IBEX ‘99 (a trade
show for boatbuilders), prompted me to inspect the hoses on my own
early-‘80s-built boat. What I found wasn’t pretty and unsafe, especially
engine hoses. If you haven’t upgraded hoses on your boat lately, read on.
Hose approved
for marine use should be Coast Guard certified, as required for
gasoline-carrying lines, or constructed to meet minimum performance and
quality standards. Though generally more expensive than non-marine-rated
hose, using such products insures greater service life and safety.
Consider these examples. When a raw-water-cooled engine develops a
blockage and the engine overheats, an automotive heater hose would likely
burst. Spill solvent on a cheap PVC hose and it quickly dissolves. A
|
  |
(left) Very soft, non-reinforced automotive heater
hose commonly found in older boats and on author’s boat for raw-water
engine intake. (right) Overtightening the hose clamp has resulted in
the thin-walled automotive heater hose being crushed. A hose failure
could sink this boat. |
ruptured
non-marine hose on an engine or gen-set raw-water connection, air
conditioning, bilge pump, head and livewell intakes or any hose connected
to a below-waterline thru-hull can sink your boat. Likewise for a leaking
cockpit drain hose — should it rain and the bilge pump can’t keep up with
the water flow, the boat will surely sink. Non-standard engine exhaust
hose with pinhole leaks can result in deadly carbon monoxide poisoning and
possible flooding. Breach an unrated diesel fuel line or holding tank hose
and you’re guaranteed to have the contents dumped into the bilge, creating
a very dangerous, or noxious, situation. Blow a non-certified gasoline
line and the boat becomes an explosive shell.
Hoses for marine
use are often labeled with the standards classification, either SAE, Coast
Guard, NMMA, ISO, UL or Lloyd’s; the manufacturer’s identification number,
usage, the year manufactured plus other classifications as specified for
each particular application. When purchasing approved hose, also examine
the construction: check that the hose ends have the same inside diameter;
examine the wall thickness as thin-walled hose easily kinks and has poor
abrasion resistance; and check that it’s reinforced with wire or synthetic
yarn (usually polyester).
Now that
marine-rated brand-name hoses are readily available, it makes good sense
to purchase the best you can afford and of the proper material and
strength rating. Since doing the research for this article, I’ve replaced
all the automotive engine hoses on my boat and now have premium quality,
smell-free head hoses. Next time you’re onboard your boat, I suggest you
inspect all the hoses and upgrade, based on the following specs, as
needed.
Fuel Hose
|
Wall
thickness of Coast Guard-certified fuel line hose (pictured) is more
than twice the thickness of automotive fuel line. |
Gasoline-carrying hoses on inboard and stern drive boats are the only ones
that must by law meet Coast Guard standards. Look for hoses labeled “SAE
J1527,” or less common, “UL-1114.” Labeling on fuel hoses also includes:
classification
of resistance to fire, either “A” for fire resistant, “B” for not fire
tested (for outboard use only); and fuel permeation, either “1”which is
the highest permeation requirements for gasoline distribution and return
lines, or “2,” a less-stringent requirement commonly used for gasoline
fuel fill and vent hoses, and all diesel hoses. There are currently no
mandatory standards for diesel or outboard engine applications.
Exhaust Hose
|
Vetus
double-steel reinforced rubber exhaust hose is very flexible, has
Lloyd’s Register of Shipping approval and rated for 100°C (212°F). |
Since 1999,
flexible rubber hose, bellows and elbows used in wet exhaust systems must
comply with SAE J2006 standards and be so labeled. This means that the
hose is temperature-rated at 593°C (1,100°F) for two minutes, the
equivalent of running the engine at full power for two minutes.Wet exhaust
hose should also be flexible, thick walled, and
resistant to
cold, heat, abrasion, antifreeze and oil. Various compounds are offered
depending on application and your budget. The less expensive high-temp
black 100% EPDM rubber withstands 121°C (250°F) maximum continuous. More
expensive is 100% silicone hose with polyester reinforcement and molded
silicone-EPDM blend withstands 176.6°C (350°F) maximum continuous. For
extreme high-heat applications, premium-priced Nomex-molded or -reinforced
100% silicone rated for 260°C (500°F) maximum continuous lasts up to six
times longer than economical black EPDM rubber hose. Additional labeling
on some brands rates the product’s flexibility: “R” for soft-wall, “R2”
for hard-wall, and “R3” for exhaust connectors. Soft-wall hose, commonly
used for straight connections, is reinforced with multiple yarn plies.
Hard-wall hose is wire- and yarn-reinforced, preferably wire sandwiched
between two plies. Flexible elbows and hose bellows with an “R3” rating
easily mold into the tightest bends to compensate for engine movement,
vibration, noise and misalignment, and reduce engine back pressure.
Engine Coolant Hose
|
Extra
thick-walled engine coolant hose (or for drain or sanitation uses)
with wire helix between two-ply reinforcement has excellent
flexibility and bend radius. |
Hoses that
circulate engine coolant water must resist kinking, heat, antifreeze and
oil. A heavy-wall, two-ply rubber hose, with or without wire reinforcing,
is recommended, or substitute premium automotive black heater hose or blue
silicone hose, both rated to meet SAE J20 standards. Some coolant hoses
are also reinforced with synthetic yarn. For high-temp applications,
Trident’s Premium Blue Silicone hose has a maximum continuous rating of
287°C (550°F).
Raw-Water Pick-up Hose
Any hose connected to a thru-hull located
below the waterline that delivers raw water to an engine, head, air
conditioning and livewell should be the best hose purchasable. Don’t rely
on corrugated hose — a rupture could sink your boat. There are no
standards for this hose, though it’s recommended to use two- ply,
wire-reinforced, heavy-wall rubber hose, the type used for engine exhaust
(SAE J2006 R2 or equivalent). Such hose won’t kink nor collapse under
suction if the raw-water screen becomes clogged.
Potable Water Hose
|
(top) White
PVC smooth-wall hose commonly used for head and potable water
applications; (middle) Premium choice odor-resistant, heavy- and
smooth-walled, reinforced, premium black rubber sanitation hose;
soft-wall portable water hose reinforced with multiple yarn plies,
commonly used for straight connections. |
According to
ABYC and NMMA standards, water hoses must be food-grade or FDA-approved,
usually PVC (polyvinyl chloride), preferably smooth-walled and opaque
rather than clear as light encourages algae growth. Never use rubber hose
as it imparts a foul smell in the water. Pressurized cold-water systems
require reinforced hose for water distribution, typically a clear or white
hose with red, blue and/or white polyester yarn tracers. Both pressurized
and non-pressurized hot-water systems, where lines carry 60°C (140°F)
water or higher, require reinforced rubber hose. Water tank fill and vent
hoses commonly use smooth-walled rigid hose. Alternatives to hose for all
applications are rigid household-type water pipe (different types for
carrying cold and hot water) and piping systems offered by Whale and
Flair-It. (For detailed information on installing and troubleshooting
freshwater systems, refer to DIY 1997-#1 issue.)
Bilge Hose
|
Cheap
multiflex corrugated hose collapses in suction applications, ruptures
easily and reduces water flow by up to 30%. |
Cheap multi-flex
corrugated hose, the stuff with the equally spaced molded cuffs, is the
worst option for bilge pump intakes or for connecting pumps to thru-hulls.
Sure it’s resistant to oil, water, easily bends around tight corners and
lasts a long time. But kink it and the hose cracks. Chafe it and it
punctures. And the corrugations and cuffs reduce water flow by 30% and
higher. (For more information on bilge hose and water volume, refer to DIY
2000#1 issue.) Most quality boatbuilders have replaced corrugated hose
with a more durable nearly-as-flexible smooth version.
Drains
Flexible, heavy-walled rubber water intake hose that doesn’t kink or
abrade is recommended for cockpit, sink and shower drains. Alternatively,
you can use smooth vinyl or PVC tubing, depending on the installation.
Sanitation Hose
|
  |
Use a smooth wall, wire-reinforced hose (top) first to
do the job before selecting the cheaper, corrugated hose (bottom). |
Sanitation hose
on boats must contain sewage that is about 30 times more concentrated,
especially vacuum-type toilets that have very low water content, than
residential sewage. This is not an easy task. Such hose must be flexible,
kink-resistant and more importantly, odor-resistant. Often the only type
offered in marine stores, and commonly installed on boats, is food-grade,
smooth-walled white PVC. Not the best selection as odor permeation is
commonplace –- before upgrading, I replaced cheap head hoses every season
as part of my spring commissioning chores.Stink-resistant alternatives,
but not readily available, are gray anti-bacterial hose and the smooth,
heavy-walled, premium-grade, less odorous, black rubber hose. Either is a
better choice than conventional PVC hose, but about twice the cost,
however, they won’t need replacing as often. Some boat owners have had
good success with Schedule 40 or Schedule 80 pipe, supported every 1.8m
(6'). Installing short hoses, minimizing connections and limiting use of
Y-valves that can trap sewage also helps to reduce odor-causing problems.
(For step-by-step head and holding tank installations and
trouble-shooting, refer to DIY 1997-#2.) Although there are no recommended
standards for sanitation hose, it’s often labeled with the type and
manufacturer. Knowing this information helps to identify your replacement
options.
Ducting
Factory-supplied flexible vinyl ducting used for heat and air conditioning
systems punctures easily. Better to replace it with more durable, heavier-
walled ducting.
Propane
Hoses used onboard for propane appliances must comply with UL 21 and must
be assembled with swaged end fittings. All installations must comply with
ABYC A1. |